How do you link identity to ideology?
Race and gender are some identities that are the
most visibly seen. Society has constructed a list of rules and ideologies for
how one should act if you are that certain identity.
This week in class I thought that ideology was an
important concept that needed to be more defined and covered, so I chose to
focus on how identity influences the ideologies we belief . . .
“Ideology” is basically an intellectual
belief system imposed upon reality, while “Identity” today is not something
given by nature or tradition but something chosen.
• Identity
is a socially and historically constructed concept. We learn about our own
identity and the identity of others through interactions with family, peers,
organizations, institutions, media and other connections we make in our
everyday life.
• Keyfacets of identity—like gender, social class, age, sexual orientation, race and
ethnicity—play significant roles in determining how we understand and
experience the world, as well as shaping the types of opportunities and
challenges we face.
• Social and cultural identity is inextricably linked to issues of power, value systems,
and ideology.
• The media uses representations—images, words, and characters or personae—to convey
specific ideas and values related to culture and identity in society.
According to Karl Marx and Engels, ideologies
perpetuate the power of the elites. Ideologies are often used with politics but
there are also gender and racial ideologies. If Western civilization continues
to use these traditional ideologies, then this favors the heterosexual white
male identity, thus keeping them in a power position.
“I say keeping men in a power position because in
the great chain of being, the white man was the being next to god, then is
woman and then animals. Transgender were not even considered.”
Gender role ideology
Gender role ideology is defined as the attitudes
and beliefs about the proper roles of women and men in the family or society.
In March of this year (2016) the American College
of Pediatricians released a statement saying that, it is child abuse to allow
children to belief that they are the opposite sex if they have normal XY and XX
sex chromosomes.
Why would some say yes?
Some critics that say gender ideology is harmful to
children would argue that No one is born with a gender. Everyone is born with a
biological sex. Gender (an awareness and sense of oneself as male or female) is
a sociological and psychological concept; not an objective biological one.
This is saying that if you don’t meet the standards
of what constitutes “being a man” or “being a woman” then you are wrong for
thinking the way you do. They also bring up how children that believe so, may
have gender dysphonia, formerly listed as Gender Identity Disorder (GID).
Summing it up to saying you have a mental disorder for thinking you are the
opposite sex, because of your make up biologically. So making a child act a certain gender role leads to oppression. This is saying that our sex
is the only one valid identity we can associate our self with because that is
how we were created.
Why would some say no
Some people criticize the credibility of the
American College of Pediatricians; they say it is not a legit organization, but
it is just a group of people spreading their biases to public. Another argument
given proves that
usage of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones are harmful. (It is
possible for someone to be completely accepting of this gender ideology while
also opposing the use of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones.) According
to the DSM-V, as many as 98% of gender confused boys and 88% of gender confused
girls eventually accept their biological sex after naturally passing through
puberty.
This document came from the American College
of Pediatrics, which can commonly be mistaken for the
American Academy of Pediatrics. There are clearly differences between
the two organizations of Pediatrics. Some say that the college is a hate group!
Even in the document it states that a great percentage of individuals will often
eventually identify their sex. To me this says that you can let the individual
believe what ever they want to believe and they will still turn out the way
they are supposed to be.
(Below is the American College of Pediatricians
versus The American Academy of Pediatricians)
^^^
The argument some may have is that The American Academy of Pediatrics is more distinguished than The American College of Pediatrics.
Racial Ideology
Racial ideology is a set of fixed beliefs about one
or more races. It's almost always utilized to
promote racial superiority over others, rather than just discussing racial
characteristics. This can also relate to how we (humans) divide the human
species into races on grounds of physical characteristics and behaviors. Within
some racial ideologies comes hegemony and colorism.
Using
hegemony, an example of race superiority would be the Ku Klux Klan and how they
believed that the white race was the superior race and all others could die.
They even did the killing them selves using bible verses to justify there
doing.
Colorism
is very complex because these racial ideologies that one may have determines
how they might treat some one based on race. An example of this could be the
ongoing “war” between light skinned blacks versus the dark skin blacks. Proving
which of the same race is more authentic by acts of masculinity, relationships with women and skin color.
^^^^
In this
video above this woman goes on a "rant" about how there is colorism within the black
race and further talks about what it means to not be black enough . . .
Dark
meaning you are more masculine (tough) and authentic
Light
meaning you are soft and not really black
This is another example of hegemony that happens within the same race with the darker skinned blacks believing they are more superior than the lighter skinned blacks.
This is another example of hegemony that happens within the same race with the darker skinned blacks believing they are more superior than the lighter skinned blacks.
Sometimes
this leads to kids acting tougher than they really are to fit in and “hang”. Leading them to a path of trouble and mistakes made.
What makes this so complex is that this could even apply to the white race, like if the environment you grew up in is made up of a mostly black population. The white kids only friends would be blacks and in order for him to 'hang" he has to talk a certain way and act a certain way.
What makes this so complex is that this could even apply to the white race, like if the environment you grew up in is made up of a mostly black population. The white kids only friends would be blacks and in order for him to 'hang" he has to talk a certain way and act a certain way.
Another
example of colorism could be successful men of color (no matter the shade of
skin). If you make it and you are surrounded by the opposite color (whites)
that are also rich, then you “sold out” on your race and you are a “uncle tom”
for conforming to white standards.
There is also race gender roles and each culture has different norms on the roles that man and woman play. Some things are masculine and feminine to other cultures. Western ideologies often mistake the exception for the norm(ideologies).
In a
podcast we listened to in class the ladies mentioned that slave owners created
these “ideologies” to turn slave against each other. Since mentioning the slave
mentality the term “uncle tom” was also used during the slavery times often referred
to blacks that turned against their own kind and conformed to the slave master.
This brings me to my question
Does one’s identity influence the ideologies they believe
in or should gender and race ideologies be enforced?
I think that this is becoming an interesting time in history when the
traditional ideology of western civilization is slowly being changed, but not
just with race but also with sex and gender.
From a previous psychology
class that I took I learned that no matter what you force on a child, the child
would grow up to be what they are meant to identify with. The environment does
have a factor in your human experiences, but also so does the role you look
like you play; is often how one will be treated in this society. Therefore
creating and living through their own personal ideologies.
WORD COUNT: 1303




No comments:
Post a Comment